Nearly $1.9 Million in Refunds to Consumers Affected by Hey Dude’s Unlawful Shipping and Review Practices

Nearly $1.9 Million in Refunds to Consumers Affected by Hey Dude’s Unlawful Shipping and Review Practices

The Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) is mailing nearly $1.9 million in refunds to thousands of customers impacted by Hey Dude, Inc.’s unfair shipping practices and manipulation of customer reviews. This follows a settlement reached in September 2023, which saw the online shoe retailer held accountable for a series of violations related to the Mail, Internet, and Telephone Order Merchandise Rule (also known as the Mail Order Rule) and the suppression of negative reviews.

Hey Dude, known for its popular casual footwear, was found to have engaged in misleading and deceptive practices that harmed consumers between 2020 and 2022. One of the key allegations was the company’s failure to notify customers of shipping delays, a violation of the Mail Order Rule, which mandates that businesses must inform consumers if an order cannot be shipped on time. In addition, when delays did occur, Hey Dude did not provide customers with the option to cancel their orders and obtain a refund. Instead, customers who did not receive their merchandise were often offered gift cards, rather than the expected cash refunds, which further exacerbated the violation of consumer rights.

Beyond shipping issues, the FTC also charged Hey Dude with manipulating customer feedback on its website. The company was found to have selectively published reviews, suppressing those that rated products poorly. Specifically, Hey Dude rejected and failed to post more than 80% of reviews that did not score four or five stars, thus giving consumers a distorted view of the product’s actual performance. This practice misled potential customers and violated the FTC Act, which prohibits businesses from engaging in deceptive advertising practices.

As part of the settlement, Hey Dude has been ordered to pay nearly $1.9 million in refunds to consumers who were affected by these practices. The FTC is sending payments to over 36,000 individuals who experienced unexpected order cancellations, shipping delays, or who were issued gift cards instead of refunds for undelivered products. These refunds are being issued through PayPal, providing consumers with a straightforward way to receive compensation for the inconvenience they experienced.

This action serves as an important reminder that businesses, especially those operating online, must adhere to consumer protection laws designed to ensure transparency and fairness. The suppression of negative reviews and failure to provide proper refunds not only undermines consumer trust but also creates an environment where dishonest business practices can thrive. The FTC’s settlement with Hey Dude sends a clear message to retailers that they must be truthful in their marketing, handle consumer complaints appropriately, and comply with regulations that protect shoppers’ rights.

With the company now under the scrutiny of the FTC, Hey Dude is required to change its practices moving forward, ensuring that future consumers are not subject to the same deceptive treatment. The case also highlights the ongoing efforts by the FTC to keep pace with the evolving landscape of online commerce, ensuring that companies operate with integrity and that consumers are fairly treated in every transaction.

The FTC said their refund program demonstrates the agency’s commitment to holding businesses accountable and ensuring that consumer rights are respected in the ever-expanding online marketplace.

If you would like to read more about this case and others, visit our Case Studies Library.

(Image Credit: iStock Photo)

This article is for information purposes only. It is not intended to be and should not be relied on as legal advice for any particular matter.